Getting Good Advice

What Is a Fiduciary, and Why Does It Matter Who Gives You Money Advice?

The short answer

A fiduciary is a person who is legally required to put your interests ahead of their own when they advise you. Not every financial professional is one. Before you take anyone's advice about your money, ask whether they are a fiduciary all the time, and get the answer in writing.

That sounds like a technicality. It isn't. It decides whose interests a recommendation is built around. It matters just as much if you have $50,000 in a 401(k) or $50 million from selling a company.

Words to know

Fiduciary
someone with a legal duty to act in your best interest. Trustees, guardians and many financial advisers carry this duty.
Duty of loyalty
your interests come before the adviser's, their firm's, or anyone paying them.
Duty of care
they have to do the homework. That means understanding your situation before recommending anything, and keeping an eye on it afterward.
Best interest (Regulation Best Interest)
a rule from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) for stockbrokers. It requires a recommendation to be in your best interest when it is made, but it doesn't create an ongoing duty to watch over your money.
Conflict of interest
any situation where the adviser earns more if you choose one option over another.

Why does it matter who is advising me?

Because how someone gets paid shapes what they recommend. That's true of a contractor, a car salesperson, or anyone you hire. Most people never ask, because financial advice looks the same from the outside. The offices are nice, the titles sound alike, and everyone says they put clients first.

The research says the differences are real. In a well-known study published by the National Bureau of Economic Research in 2012, trained actors posed as ordinary investors and visited real advisers. Advisers often nudged them toward higher-cost funds. They did it even when the "investor" already owned a sensible, low-cost portfolio. Most of those advisers probably believed they were helping. The pull came from how they were paid.

A 2009 study in the Review of Financial Studies found something similar. Mutual funds sold through brokers did worse than funds people bought directly, even before counting sales charges.

Is a fiduciary the same as "acting in my best interest"?

Not quite. Since 2020, brokers have had to make recommendations that are in your best interest at the time they make them. That was an improvement. But a fiduciary adviser's duty usually covers the whole relationship. They must watch for problems, tell you about conflicts, and avoid conflicts where they can.

Registered investment advisers have been held to a fiduciary duty since the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, a duty the U.S. Supreme Court confirmed in 1963. Since 2019, CFP® professionals have been required to act as fiduciaries whenever they give financial advice, not only during a formal planning project.

Does this matter if I'm not rich?

Yes, and it matters just as much if you are. People with modest savings feel every dollar of unnecessary cost. People with large or complicated finances get more recommendations: insurance, trusts, business decisions, ways to invest a windfall. Each one is another chance for a conflict to creep in.

Having money doesn't mean you know the rules about money advice. Plenty of successful people have never been told any of this, because nobody's job was to tell them.

What should a fiduciary relationship look like?

  • They learn before they recommend. They ask about your whole picture first: income, debts, family, goals, taxes, insurance, and any business you own.
  • Advice is written down. You get recommendations in writing, with the reasons and the alternatives they considered.
  • Conflicts are disclosed up front. You should never find out about a conflict by accident.
  • They keep watching. They follow up when your life, the markets or tax laws change.

Your one move

Ask anyone who advises you, or wants to, one question:

"Are you a fiduciary at all times when you advise me, and will you put that in writing?"

A clear, quick "yes" is a good sign. An answer like "In most situations" or "It depends on the account" tells you what you need to know.

Next steps

Sources

  1. Mullainathan, S., Noeth, M., & Schoar, A. (2012). The Market for Financial Advice: An Audit Study. NBER Working Paper 17929.
  2. Bergstresser, D., Chalmers, J., & Tufano, P. (2009). Assessing the costs and benefits of brokers in the mutual fund industry. Review of Financial Studies, 22(10).
  3. SEC v. Capital Gains Research Bureau, Inc., 375 U.S. 180 (1963).
  4. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (2019). Regulation Best Interest, Release No. 34-86031.
  5. CFP Board (2019). Code of Ethics and Standards of Conduct.