Getting Good Advice

Your Financial Privacy: What an Advisor Can and Can't Share

The short answer

Federal law requires financial firms to tell you, in a privacy notice, what they collect about you and who they share it with. They must let you stop some kinds of sharing and protect your data. But the protections have gaps. In particular, many firms can share your information with their own sister companies without asking you. Read the notice, opt out where you can, and ask direct questions.

When you work with an adviser, you hand over a map of your financial life: income, accounts, debts, family, health, business and estate plans. That map is valuable to fraudsters and to companies that want to sell you things.

Words to know

Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA)
the 1999 federal law that sets basic privacy rules for banks, brokers, insurers and investment advisers.
Regulation S-P
the SEC's version of those rules for brokers and SEC-registered advisers. It was updated in 2024 to add stronger data-breach rules.
Nonpublic personal information
the protected stuff, meaning account balances, income, Social Security number, and nearly anything you tell your adviser.
Privacy notice
a document explaining what the firm collects and shares. You get it when you become a client.
Opt out
your right to tell the firm not to share your information in certain ways.
Affiliate
a company under the same corporate umbrella, like a bank that owns a brokerage and an insurance company.

What must my adviser tell me?

The privacy notice must explain:

  • What kinds of information they collect: from you, from your transactions, and from outside sources like credit bureaus.
  • What they share with affiliates and with outside companies.
  • How you can opt out of the sharing you're allowed to block.
  • In general terms, how they protect your data.

Here's the catch. Research on required disclosures, including a well-known 2011 review in the University of Pennsylvania Law Review, finds that most people never read them. The notice tends to arrive as an insert with a statement and go straight in the recycling bin. That costs you, because your opt-out right only works if you use it.

What can I stop, and what can't I?

You can usually stop: sharing with unrelated outside companies for marketing.

You usually can't stop:

  • Sharing with affiliates. At big financial companies with banks, brokerages and insurers under one roof, your information can move between them.
  • Sharing with service providers. That includes the firm that holds your account, software vendors and auditors, as long as there is a contract protecting your data.
  • Sharing required by law, such as a court order or a regulator's request.
  • Sharing to prevent fraud.

So the opt-out covers less than most people assume, especially at large firms.

What must firms do to protect my data?

Firms must have a written program to safeguard client information. Under the SEC's 2024 update, covered firms must also have a plan for responding to breaches. They must notify affected clients within 30 days of learning that sensitive information was, or likely was, accessed without permission.

That matters because detailed financial profiles enable more than simple account theft. The usual danger isn't a stranger guessing your password. It's someone who knows enough about your accounts and family to impersonate you, redirect a wire transfer, or take advantage of a confusing moment such as a death in the family.

Does this matter if I don't have much money?

Yes. Identity theft hurts at every income level, and recovering from it costs time and money. If you have more wealth or own a business, the profile your adviser holds is richer, and so is the reward for stealing it. Either way, the rules are the same and so are the questions to ask.

Your one move

Ask your adviser:

  1. "Can I see your current privacy notice?"
  2. "Is your firm part of a larger company, like a bank, broker or insurer? Who can my information be shared with without my permission?"
  3. "Do you share client information with outside companies for marketing? If so, how do I opt out?"
  4. "Which outside vendors can see my account information?"
  5. "What happens, and how fast will I hear, if my information is ever exposed?"

If there's an opt-out, use it today.

Next steps

Sources

  1. Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act of 1999, 15 U.S.C. §§ 6801–6809.
  2. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (2024). Amendments to Regulation S-P, Release No. 34-100155.
  3. Ben-Shahar, O., & Schneider, C. (2011). The failure of mandated disclosure. University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 159(3).
  4. Acquisti, A., Taylor, C., & Wagman, L. (2016). The economics of privacy. Journal of Economic Literature, 54(2).