Investing

10 Mental Shortcuts That Cost You Money

The short answer

Our brains use shortcuts, called biases, that work well in daily life but lead to predictable money mistakes: holding losers too long, chasing what just went up, trusting ourselves too much, and freezing when we should act. Smart, successful people are just as prone to them, often more, because success breeds confidence. You can't switch biases off. You can build rules and habits that catch them.

Every bias on this list has a price. Most people pay it for years without noticing.

Words to know

Behavioral finance
the study of how psychology affects financial decisions.
Bias
a consistent mental tilt that pushes decisions away from what the facts support.
Heuristic
a mental shortcut or rule of thumb.

The ten shortcuts

BiasWhat it sounds likeWhat it costs
Loss aversion"I'll sell once it gets back to what I paid."Holding losers, avoiding sensible risk
Overconfidence"I know this company / industry better than the market."Concentration, too much trading
Anchoring"It was $80 last year, so $50 is a bargain."Judging by an irrelevant past price
Recency"The last three years were great, so the next three will be."Buying high, selling low
Herding"Everyone I know is buying it."Joining bubbles late
ConfirmationOnly reading news that agrees with youMissing warning signs
Mental accounting"That's house money, so I can gamble it."Treating dollars differently depending on where they came from
Status quo"I'll deal with it later."Outdated beneficiaries, idle cash, no plan
Familiarity"I like owning what I know."Too much in your employer, your industry or your home region
Endowment"My business / house / stock is worth more because it's mine."Overvaluing what you own; deals that fall apart

Why do successful people fall for these?

Because many of the same instincts built their success. An entrepreneur's confidence, focus on one bet, and refusal to quit are strengths in business and costly in a portfolio. A surgeon's or engineer's skill in their field can make them overconfident about a field they never studied. Research by economists Brad Barber and Terrance Odean found that the investors who traded most earned the least. Overconfidence was a leading suspect.

How do you guard against them?

  1. Write rules in advance: target allocation, when to rebalance, how much any one holding can be.
  2. Automate: contributions, rebalancing, required withdrawals.
  3. Use checklists for big decisions: a sale, a purchase, a new investment.
  4. Slow down. Wait 48 hours before acting on a market move or a hot tip.
  5. Get a second opinion from someone with no stake in the outcome.

Your one move

Pick the two biases from the table that sound most like you. For each, write one rule that would stop it. For example: "No single stock over 10% of my portfolio," or "I rebalance every January no matter what." Tape the rules where you check your accounts.

Next steps

Sources

  1. Kahneman, D., & Tversky, A. (1979). Prospect theory: An analysis of decision under risk. Econometrica, 47(2).
  2. Barber, B., & Odean, T. (2000). Trading is hazardous to your wealth. Journal of Finance, 55(2).
  3. Thaler, R. (1999). Mental accounting matters. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 12(3).