# How to Tell If Your Investments Are Actually Doing Well

Source: https://theultimateguidetomoney.com/library/investing/how-to-tell-if-your-investments-are-actually-doing-well/
Author: Kris Garlewicz, CFP®, CRPS® · Reviewed November 16, 2026

**The short answer.** A good return is one that's on track for your goals, earned with a level of risk you agreed to, and compared fairly against the right benchmark, after fees and taxes. The headline number on a statement often isn't that. Also, the return a fund reports and the return *you* earned can be very different, because of when you added or pulled money.

The number on your statement isn't your result.

## Words to know

- **Time-weighted return:** how the investments themselves performed, ignoring your deposits and withdrawals. Used to judge a manager.
- **Money-weighted (personal) return:** what you actually earned, given when you added or removed money. Used to judge your experience.
- **Benchmark:** a fair yardstick, such as a blended index that matches your mix of stocks and bonds.
- **Net of fees:** after all costs are taken out.
- **Risk-adjusted return:** return compared with how much the portfolio swung up and down.

## Why can my return differ from my fund's return?

Because timing matters. Morningstar's latest *Mind the Gap* study found that the average dollar invested in U.S. mutual funds and ETFs earned 8.7% a year over the 10 years ending in 2025. That was 1.2 percentage points less than the funds themselves returned, a gap explained by when investors bought and sold ([Morningstar](https://www.morningstar.com/lp/mind-the-gap?con=15949)). Buying after a run-up and selling after a drop quietly costs a lot.

## How do I judge performance fairly?

1. **Compare to the right benchmark.** A 60% stock / 40% bond portfolio should be compared with a 60/40 blend of indexes, not with the S&P 500.
2. **Look at long periods.** At least one full market cycle, five to ten years, not one quarter or one year.
3. **Use returns after fees.** Ask whether the reported figure is before or after advisory and fund fees.
4. **Consider taxes** in taxable accounts. Two portfolios with the same return can leave you different amounts after tax.
5. **Check the risk.** Higher returns that came with much bigger drops may not have been a good trade for you.
6. **Measure against your plan.** The real question: are you on track for the goals you set?

## What are the warning signs?

- Statements that show performance only for flattering periods.
- No clear benchmark, or a benchmark that changes.
- Fees you can't find on the statement.
- Lots of trading with no clear reason.
- Every review focused on returns, and never on your goals.

## Does this apply to wealthy families?

Especially. Complex portfolios spread across several advisers, private funds and accounts are the hardest to measure, and the easiest to overpay for. A consolidated report covering every account, with one fair benchmark, is worth asking for at any level of wealth.

## Your one move

Ask your adviser, or your account website, for three numbers for the last five years: your personal return after all fees, the return of a fair blended benchmark, and the total fees you paid in dollars. If no one can give you all three, that's your answer.

## Sources

- [Morningstar, Mind the Gap](https://www.morningstar.com/lp/mind-the-gap?con=15949) (10 years ended Dec. 31, 2025).
- CFA Institute, Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS) on time- and money-weighted returns.

---
General education from The Ultimate Guide to Money, brought to you by ProsperiFi LLC, an investment adviser registered with the State of Illinois. Not individualized advice.
