# Index Funds vs. Active Funds: What the Evidence Says

Source: https://theultimateguidetomoney.com/library/investing/index-funds-vs-active-funds-what-the-evidence-says/
Author: Kris Garlewicz, CFP®, CRPS® · Reviewed November 16, 2026

**The short answer.** An **index fund** simply owns the market, or a slice of it, at low cost. An **active fund** pays managers to pick investments and try to beat the market. Year after year, most active funds fall short of their index after fees, and the longer the period, the larger the share that lag. Active management can still have a role in certain markets or for specific goals. But low cost and broad diversification are the starting point most evidence supports.

The industry earns more from complexity. The evidence favors simplicity.

## Words to know

- **Index fund / ETF:** a fund that tracks a market index, such as the S&P 500, instead of trying to beat it.
- **Active fund:** a fund whose managers choose investments to try to beat a benchmark.
- **Expense ratio:** the yearly fee a fund charges, as a percentage of what you hold.
- **Benchmark:** the index a fund is measured against.
- **SPIVA:** S&P Dow Jones Indices' long-running scorecard comparing active funds with their benchmarks.

## What does the evidence show?

In 2025, 79% of actively managed large-cap U.S. stock funds underperformed the S&P 500 ([S&P Dow Jones Indices](https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/spiva/article/spiva-us-year-end-2025/)). Over three and five years, 67% and 89% respectively fell short ([S&P Dow Jones Indices](https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/index-tv/article/spiva-by-the-numbers-a-global-perspective/)). In the 15-year period ending in 2024, not a single U.S. stock fund category had a majority of active managers beat its benchmark ([ICFS](https://icfs.com/financial-knowledge-center/spiva-scorecard-results)).

Some managers do beat the market, but it's hard to tell in advance which ones. Past winners rarely keep winning year after year.

## Why do most active funds lag?

- **Costs.** Higher fees, trading costs and, in taxable accounts, more taxable gains.
- **Math.** Before costs, all investors together earn the market return. After costs, the average active dollar has to trail it.
- **Competition.** Professionals mostly trade with other professionals.

## Is there still a place for active management?

Possibly: in less-efficient markets, for specific tax or income goals, or in areas where indexing is awkward. Some people value a manager who will hold more cash or avoid certain holdings. If you choose active funds, keep costs low, know exactly what you're paying for, and judge them over full market cycles, not one good year.

## Does wealth change the answer?

Not much. Wealthy investors are often offered more expensive active options, from private funds to custom portfolios, and the same math applies. More money doesn't buy a way around fees. What matters at every level is cost, diversification, taxes and the discipline to stay invested.

## Your one move

List every fund you own with its expense ratio. For each actively managed fund, look up how it did against its benchmark over 10 years, after fees. Ask whoever recommended it: "What am I getting for the extra cost?"

## Sources

- S&P Dow Jones Indices, [SPIVA U.S. Year-End 2025](https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/spiva/article/spiva-us-year-end-2025/) and [SPIVA by the Numbers](https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/index-tv/article/spiva-by-the-numbers-a-global-perspective/).
- [ICFS](https://icfs.com/financial-knowledge-center/spiva-scorecard-results): summary of SPIVA U.S. Year-End 2024 15-year results.
- Sharpe, W. (1991). The arithmetic of active management. *Financial Analysts Journal*, 47(1).
- Past performance does not guarantee future results.

---
General education from The Ultimate Guide to Money, brought to you by ProsperiFi LLC, an investment adviser registered with the State of Illinois. Not individualized advice.
