Investing

The Kinds of Investment Risk, and the One That Wipes Out Most Wealth

The short answer

"Risk" isn't one thing. Market drops, inflation, rising interest rates, borrowers who don't pay, investments you can't sell, and bad timing are all different risks. The one that most often destroys family wealth is concentration: too much riding on one company, one industry, one property or one decision. Market risk can be waited out. A single holding that goes to zero can't.

Most people fear the risk they see on the news, and ignore the one sitting in their own accounts.

Words to know

Volatility
how much and how fast prices bounce around.
Systematic (market) risk
risk that hits nearly everything at once, like a recession or a crash. Diversification can't remove it.
Unsystematic (specific) risk
risk tied to one company or industry. Diversification can largely remove it.
Permanent loss
money that never comes back, as opposed to a temporary decline.

What are the main risks?

RiskWhat it meansExample
MarketBroad prices fallA bear market cuts stock values 30%
ConcentrationToo much in one holdingMost of your wealth is in your employer's or your own company's stock
InflationMoney buys less over timeCash or fixed payments lose buying power
Interest rateRising rates lower bond pricesA long-term bond falls when rates jump
CreditA borrower doesn't pay you backA company bond or private loan defaults
LiquidityYou can't sell quickly at a fair priceA private fund or real estate you can't exit for years
SequenceBad returns arrive at the worst timeA crash in your first year of retirement
BehavioralYour own decisions hurt returnsSelling in a panic, buying in a frenzy

Why is concentration the big one?

Because individual stocks are far riskier than the market as a whole. Hendrik Bessembinder's 2018 study in the Journal of Financial Economics found that most individual U.S. stocks over their lifetimes earned less than one-month Treasury bills. About 4% of companies accounted for all of the stock market's net wealth creation. Owning the whole market captures those few big winners. Owning one company bets that yours is among them.

Concentration builds a lot of fortunes, as founders and early employees know. Keeping it is what loses fortunes.

Who's most exposed?

  • Business owners whose company is most of their net worth.
  • Executives and employees with large holdings of company stock, plus a paycheck from the same company.
  • Heirs who inherit a single stock, property or business and hold it out of loyalty.
  • Retirees who reach for yield in one sector or one private deal.

Your one move

Add up your net worth, including your home, business, retirement accounts and any company stock. Then find the single largest holding. If any one company, property or deal is more than about 20% of the total, write down what would happen to your plan if it lost half its value. Then decide whether that's a risk you're choosing, or one you just haven't looked at.

Next steps

Sources

  1. Bessembinder, H. (2018). Do stocks outperform Treasury bills? Journal of Financial Economics, 129(3).
  2. The 20% figure is a common planning rule of thumb, not a regulatory standard.