When does converting make sense?
- Low-income years. Early retirement before Social Security and required withdrawals begin. A sabbatical, a gap between jobs, or a slow year for your business.
- Market drops. If your IRA falls 25%, converting the same shares costs 25% less in tax, and the recovery happens tax-free inside the Roth.
- When you expect higher rates later, whether from big required withdrawals, rising tax rates, or a surviving spouse filing as single.
- For heirs. Children who inherit a Roth generally don't owe income tax on withdrawals. That can matter if they'll be in high brackets themselves.
When does it usually not make sense?
- When you're in your peak tax bracket and expect a lower one later.
- When you'd have to pay the tax out of the converted money itself. That shrinks the benefit, and before 59½ it can trigger a penalty.
- When the extra income would push you over a costly threshold, such as a Medicare surcharge two years later. For 2026, the Part B surcharge starts above $109,000 of income for single filers and $218,000 for joint filers (NerdWallet).
- When you plan to leave the account to charity. Charities don't pay income tax anyway.
How do people usually do it?
In pieces over several years, not all at once. A common approach: each year, project your income and convert just enough to fill your current bracket. Then pay the tax from savings outside the retirement account. That spreads the tax across low-rate years instead of stacking it into one.
This works for people at many income levels. A retired teacher with a $300,000 IRA and a business owner with $4 million in a 401(k) can both benefit from converting in low-income years, just with different amounts.
Your one move
Before year-end, estimate this year's taxable income and find which bracket you're in. If there's room left in a low bracket, ask your tax preparer or adviser to model a partial conversion before December 31.