Why does the order matter?
Here's a simple example. Start with $1 million and withdraw $50,000 at the start of the year. If the market then falls 25%, you're left with about $712,500. To get back to $1 million, you'd need a gain of about 40%, and you're still withdrawing every year while you wait.
The same 25% drop at age 50, while you're still adding money, often turns into a buying opportunity. At 66 it can permanently shrink what's left.
Who is most exposed?
- New retirees, especially in the first five years.
- People who retire with most of their money in stocks.
- People with high withdrawal rates or little guaranteed income.
- People who sell a business and then live off the proceeds right away.
The risk scales with the dollars, but the math is the same for a $500,000 retirement and a $20 million one.
How do people defend against it?
- Keep a spending reserve. One to two years of withdrawals in cash or short-term bonds, so you don't have to sell stocks in a downturn.
- Be flexible. Agree in advance to trim spending, such as skipping a big trip or holding back an inflation raise, in years after markets fall.
- Cover essential spending with guaranteed income. Social Security, a pension or an income annuity can cover the basics. Delaying Social Security raises that floor.
- Lower risk around the retirement date. Many people gradually shift some money from stocks to bonds in the years just before and after retiring, then rebuild later.
- Watch your withdrawal rate. The higher it is, the less room you have for a bad start.
Your one move
If you're within five years of retiring, or recently retired, work out how many years of spending you could cover without selling a single stock. If the answer is under one year, build that reserve now.