How do the main options compare?
| Default LLC / sole prop | S-corp election | C-corp | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Federal income tax | Owner's personal rates | Owner's personal rates | 21% at the company, plus tax on dividends |
| Payroll / self-employment tax | On all profit | On salary only | On salary only |
| QBI deduction | Possible | Possible | No |
| Complexity | Lowest | Payroll, separate return | Separate return, corporate formalities |
| Good fit | Early stage, lower profit | Steady profit well above a fair salary | Reinvesting heavily, outside investors, possible QSBS sale |
When does an S-corp election pay off?
Usually once profit is comfortably above what a fair salary for your role would be. Say profit is $250,000 and a reasonable salary is $120,000. Payroll tax applies to the $120,000, not the full $250,000. But the savings shrink above the Social Security wage base, and payroll costs, state taxes and lower Social Security credits eat into them. Pay yourself too little and you risk an IRS challenge.
When does a C-corp make sense?
When profit stays in the company to fund growth, when there are many or outside investors, or when founders may qualify to exclude a big gain on a future sale under the small-business stock rules. Those rules were expanded for stock acquired after July 4, 2025 (Wolters Kluwer). Paying most profit out as dividends usually costs more than a pass-through would.
What else drives the decision?
State taxes, future sale plans (buyers often prefer buying assets to buying stock), retirement plan design, owner salaries, multiple owners, and the cost of changing later. Converting from a C-corp to an S-corp, or back, has its own tax traps.
Your one move
Ask your CPA for a side-by-side estimate of last year's total tax, income plus payroll, under your current structure and the next most likely alternative. If the difference is meaningful, and your plans for growth or sale have changed, schedule a structure review.