Protection

Annuities: When They Help and When They're Just Being Sold

The short answer

An annuity is a contract with an insurance company. You pay money in, and in return you get guaranteed income, tax-deferred growth, or both. Simple income annuities can be a genuinely useful way to turn savings into a paycheck you can't outlive. Many other annuities, especially complex variable and indexed products, come with high fees, long surrender periods and sales commissions that make them easier to sell than to justify. The type matters more than the label.

Annuities aren't inherently bad. They're inherently misunderstood, and often oversold.

Words to know

Immediate (income) annuity
you hand over a lump sum and get guaranteed payments, often for life, starting right away.
Deferred income annuity
the same idea, but payments start years later. A QLAC is a version allowed inside IRAs that can delay required withdrawals.
Fixed annuity / MYGA
pays a guaranteed interest rate for a set number of years, like a CD from an insurer.
Fixed indexed annuity
credits interest based on an index, such as the S&P 500, with caps and limits.
Variable annuity
invested in funds, often with optional guarantee riders, and usually the highest fees.
Surrender charge
a penalty for withdrawing early, often lasting 5–10 years.
1035 exchange
a tax-free swap from one annuity to another.

When can an annuity help?

  • Covering essential retirement spending with guaranteed income, alongside Social Security and any pension, so markets can't disrupt the basics.
  • Insuring against a long life: a deferred income annuity can start paying in your 80s.
  • A safe, fixed rate for a set period, as an alternative to CDs or bonds.
  • People who worry about running out, and value a guaranteed check over flexibility.

When should you be cautious?

  • Inside an IRA or 401(k) that's already tax-deferred, a deferred annuity's main tax benefit adds nothing.
  • When you might need the money soon, because of surrender charges.
  • When the illustration is complicated: caps, participation rates, bonuses and riders you can't explain back in your own words.
  • When total yearly costs are high, as with variable annuities stacking fund, contract and rider fees.
  • When it's pitched as a cure-all, or as an urgent "limited time" offer.

Annuity sales often pay the seller a commission. That doesn't make every recommendation wrong, but it's a reason to ask how the person is paid.

Does wealth change the answer?

Somewhat. Retirees with modest savings may benefit most from turning part of them into lifetime income. Wealthy retirees can usually self-insure against a long life, but some still value a guaranteed floor. At every level, the questions are the same: what problem is this solving, and what does it cost?

Your one move

If you own an annuity, request a current statement and a fee summary. Note the type, all yearly fees, the surrender schedule, and any riders you're paying for. If you're being offered one, ask: "What are all the costs and surrender charges, how are you paid, and what would a simple income annuity or a bond do instead?"

Next steps

Sources

  1. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Investor.gov: "Annuities" and "Variable Annuities: What You Should Know."
  2. FINRA investor insights on fixed indexed and variable annuities.